The problem

Trials take forever, convictions rarely come,so no one cares to follow the law.

India's courts are not slow because judges are idle. They are slow because nearly every accused denies everything, and denying costs nothing.

Pendency due to dishonesty

Right now, in every Indian court,lying is free.

4.1 crore
criminal cases stuck in district courts, and each denial adds a trial to the queue
Source: NJDG, Oct 2026
below 1%
of criminal cases ended in a guilty plea in 2022 (19,135 of 1.7 crore)
Source: NCRB 2022
5.9 crore
cases pending across district courts and High Courts
Source: NJDG, Oct 2026
85–98%
of convictions come by plea in common-law peers: 98% in the US, 91% in England and Wales
Source: US Courts FY2025; CPS 2024–25; Paolini et al., JELS 2025

Why is lying rampant in Indian courts? Perjury is effectively risk-free.

  • BNSS s. 215 makes 32 obstruction-of-justice laws toothless for lies told in or about a court case. Neither the victim nor the police can set them in motion.
  • Only the court can start a perjury case. The judge has to become the complainant, so it rarely happens.
  • So the guilty deny, delay and wait, and the queue grows.

NCRB 2022; NJDG Oct 2026; Swaran Singh v. State of Punjab (2000) 5 SCC 668

Twenty years on

Parliament passed the law twice,but left out the tools to make it work.

  1. 2005–06
    Plea-bargaining chapter added to the CrPC by the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2005; in force 5 July 2006.
  2. 2023
    Re-enacted in the BNSS, adding a 30-day window and first-offender concessions. The core impediments remain.
Settled
  • An accused may plead and receive a lesser sentence
  • The plea is judicially supervised and voluntary
  • The plea is not a confession at any later trial
Missing
  • A sentencing baseline to measure the concession
  • Relief from the victim's veto, and notice to the accused
  • An enforceable law against falsehood
Why almost no one pleads guilty

Four flaws in the law,one fatal.

01 · s. 291 BNSS

The victim can block any plea deal

The victim's agreement is a precondition. Dispositions die at that point, or are bought.

02 · s. 293 BNSS

No sentencing guidelines

None were ever framed. Nobody can say what a plea is worth.

03 · ss. 289–290 BNSS

The accused is never told of the option

No notice at arrest, remand or charge, and only for offences up to seven years.

04 · s. 215 BNSS

Lying in court goes unpunished

Only the court may complain of perjury, and it rarely does. No concession can beat a free acquittal.

The first three are procedural. The fourth decides whether they matter at all.

Why nobody fears the law

When breaking a rule costs nothing,ignoring it is the smart choice.

90%
of criminal cases for trial still pending at year-end
Source: NCRB 2024
12+ yrs
for a case to pass through three courts
Source: DAKSH 2023
14th
India's rule-of-law rank among the 18 G20 countries ranked
Source: WJP 2025
Pollution
88,400+
environment cases pending trial (2022); the Environment Protection Act backlog alone needs about 34 years to clear
Source: NCRB 2022 via Down To Earth
Food adulteration
1 in 5
food samples tested failed standards over five years (1.86 lakh of 8.86 lakh)
Source: MoS Health, Rajya Sabha, Jul 2026
Spurious drugs
593 → 35
spurious-drug cases (2015–19) → convictions; most still pending
Source: LS Committee on Chemicals, 2024
Corruption
7,229
CBI corruption cases pending trial, 409 of them for over 20 years
Source: CVC Annual Report 2025

Perjury laws as a shortcut offence

It takes years to prove pollution, adulteration or fraud, but days to prove a sworn lie, or a conspiracy once one insider cooperates. When lying costs, obeying is the cheaper choice.

The cost of failure

Clogged courts,crowded jails.

Only about 1.3 lakh convicts are in India's prisons, against 62 lakh crimes registered in 2023 alone. Three in four prisoners are still waiting for their trial.

NCRB crime and prison statistics 2022–23

Share of convictions that come by plea
  • United States98%United States: 98% of criminal cases resolved by plea
  • England & Wales91%England & Wales: 91% of criminal cases resolved by plea
  • Common-law peers85–98%Common-law peers: 85–98% of criminal cases resolved by plea
  • India1–2%India: 1–2% of criminal cases resolved by plea

Same measure for all four. US: US Courts, Judicial Business FY2025. England & Wales: CPS Annual Report 2024–25. Common-law peers, 2019: Paolini et al., JELS 2025. India (Chapter XXIII plea bargaining only): NCRB Crime in India 2019–24.

Truth alone triumphs.Help make it the default.

Team Satyug runs on the time, expertise and voices of people who want justice within a year. Add yours.